Thursday, February 11

A walkable grocery thought experiment

Randal O'Toole has proposed a thought experiment that he uses to "debunk the smart growth myth" of the ideal walkable neighborhood grocery store.

"For smart growth to work, then population densities must be high enough for businesses to have enough customers within walking distance to keep them going. Smart growth won't work if businesses in pedestrian-friendly neighborhoods must attract hordes of auto drivers from other areas in order to survive. A modern large supermarket needs to draw patrons from a community of about 40,000 people. This is known as the trade population for this kind of store.

Joel Garreau says that, as a rule of thumb, 'the farthest distance an American will willingly walk before getting into a car' is 600 feet. However, 'if you do everything you can to make casual use of the automobile inconvenient at the same time that you make walking pleasant and attractive, you maybe, just maybe, can up the distance an American will willingly walk to 1,500 feet'...

The population density required to place 40,000 people within 1,500 feet of a grocery store is almost 124,000 people per square mile. That's about two-and-one-half times the density of Manhattan."
Therefore, smart growth won't work. QED.

O'Toole has asked a worthwhile question but plugged in the wrong numbers to answer it. Out of curiosity, I'd like to take a closer look at this hypothetical scenario to see how feasible the walkable grocery may really be.
Customer Base. O’Toole uses the concept of trade population, but this is begging the question. His trade population number is generated assuming an automobile-oriented environment, which is exactly what the proposed scenario is an alternative to. The more objective measure is the actual pool of customers a large grocery draws from. To get a feel for this I counted all of the food sources that serve the Charlottesville-Albemarle area. I came up with 14 large "modern grocery stores," between 30,000 and 60,000 sq. feet. This does not include:
  • medium-sized full-service grocers
  • about a half dozen health food stores
  • specialty ethnic food stores
  • big box stores like Target that sell food
  • dozens of small convenience stores
I'm only counting the kinds of places O'Toole considers an unreasonable sacrifice to do without.

Taking the combined service area's population to be 134,086 from current ACS data (Charlottesville and Albemarle County), this breaks down to about one large grocery store per 9500 people. APA has determined the average customer base for a supermarket in the U.S. to be 8,412 , but I’ll just stick with my more conservative 9500.

Modal Split. O'Toole, as usual, characterizes the smart growth position as something far more extreme than anyone would actually propose: a 100% walking grocery store, as if bicycles, transit, and automobiles do not exist at all. The term walkable means able to be walked to, not only walked to. Every smart growth proponent I know would actually hope to see a multimodal balance to allow an array of transportation options. For the sake of this scenario, let's suppose our store has 50% walkers (with some cyclists included in here), 25% transit users, and 25% drivers.

Walking Distance. If you ignore Garreau's snarkiness, the 1,500 foot number is an alright estimate for typical behavior in a pedestrian-friendly environment. Walking 600 feet will seem intolerable if it's between the Best Buy and the Bed, Bath, and Beyond through a parking lot and grass berm, but Charlottesville's downtown pedestrian mall is 2,100 feet long and people will regularly walk its length for an errand because it is so enjoyable. A more objective way to go about this would be to fix the travel time. Apparently, the average drive to the grocery store currently takes about 20 minutes, including the walk from the parking lot. At a leisurely pace, the average walker could traverse about 3,000 feet in 20 minutes. I'll stick with the 1,500 foot number, noting that this will cut the travel time in half even for the furthest walkers.

Needed Density. Considering all of these conditions, a back-of-the-envelope calculation shows that this grocer could be supported with a population density of 18,885 people per square mile surrounding it. This is about half the density of Brooklyn. If this still seems unreasonably high, it should be noted that this is only the density for one quarter of a square mile area. In theory, it could be surrounded by a greenbelt of parkland and have no effect on the calculation.

Charlottesville's new Market Street Market serves a walkable neighborhood
The more important question that I have not addressed is whether easy access to a “large modern grocery store” really adds much to quality of life. Granted that more choices are usually better than fewer, but is a whole wall of ketchup options that much more preferable than one or two choices. Psychologists for a while have been pointing to the phenomenon of too many choices, leading to customer confusion and even anxiety, so much so that major retailers have begun simplifying their selections and stepping up quality control. New corporations like Trader Joes are mastering this market.

There’s no reason why a medium-scaled grocer could not carry almost anything the average household would want on a much smaller footprint. And rather than singling out a one-size-fits-all shopping location, whether you're preparing Thanksgiving dinner or picking up milk, it's easy to imagine a full spectrum of grocery stores organized between convenience and selection. Walk to the neighborhood store twice a week; take a longer trip to Costco every two months.


Dan Lorentz said...

Great post.

I'm now inspired to do some of my own back of the envelope calculations about the feasibility of grocery store locations in various neighborhoods in my town, Athens, Ga.

Here's a wishful post I did a while ago about a small format but full-service coming to my neighborhood:

Josh Grigsby said...

Nice. Great, logical debunking of another urban myth. How did we get along without big box type stores for all those centuries?

In my old neighborhood of Santa Monica, we could walk to two small Whole Foods Markets, a smallish-but-still-full-service chain grocery store, a large chain grocery store, and numerous boutique artisanal shops—all of which drew the bulk of their customer base from the surrounding neighborhoods. The overall population density in Santa Monica is only around 10k/sq.mi., and the neighborhoods I'm talking about are some of the city's least dense, with mostly single family houses and small (4-6 unit) apartment buildings.

Daniel said...

Dan, I had never heard of the chain you mention in your post. What a great idea. Food is so central to the life of a neighborhood, and I think its just starting to get the attention it deserves.

Josh, your experience matches my own. Lots of smaller stores manage to do fine. We walk to a market with a butcher, baker, and local foods vendor in about 5 minutes, but it is high-end so we can't do all of our shopping there. Another medium-sized store is within a 5 minute bike - great prices for standard food. A new store has just opened to serve a walkable neighborhood in Charlottesville. As far as I can tell it has no parking actually, just fit within the existing building frontages. Prices are reasonable and selection is fine enough for basic needs. This is certainly being done here.

I've just added a picture of the market I forgot to post earlier.

kmccaskey said...


I've been reading your blog since we share urbanism interests - but this post hit home (since my husband & I run a neighborhood specialty grocery).

We have a small selection and an even smaller neighborhood, but, the appeal to walk to the corner for an item has served us well. We're in the same location as a grocery that existed in our historic neighborhood in 1881 - we like to think the walkable, local food trend is coming back after 120+ years.

Next time you are on this side of the mountain, please drop in - we're in Staunton (George Bowers Grocery).

Daniel said...


Thanks for leaving a comment. I love Staunton. Catherine Redfearn and I worked on pedestrian and bicycle components of a Green Infrastructure Plan last fall for the city, Amy Arnold in particular. I go a chance to visit about a half dozen times and explored all over the downtown and surrounding areas. I will stop in for a bite to eat if I'm back over there at some point.

LH said...

Daniel, I found this very enjoyable (as did my co-workers, who I shared it with), and appreciate you taking the time to follow through on the numbers.

James D said...

Yes, the 40,000 figure is way out. I'm sure we all know of large grocery stores located in or on the outskirts of towns of 5,000-10,000 people with the next settlement of a similar size 30-70 miles away. So O'Toole's thought experiment fails big time.

Dave Reid said...

In downtown Milwaukee (East Town) we actually have two full service grocery stores withing two blocks of each other.

CarFree Stupidity said...

The Safeway in the Pearl district in Portland and various Trader Joes, Whole Foods, and local convinient stores in Portland all seemed to be doing fine with very little auto customers.

Reid Davis said...

Nicely done. I've never seen an Randal O'Tool(e) argument or analysis supposedly debunking smart growth or favoring the automobile that didn't crumble under more rigorous vetting.

It's frustrating to be repeatedly confronted with a rhetorical opponent who lacks even a basic shred of intellectual honesty. I'm convinced he knows he's cooking the books, and he doesn't care.

Anonymous said...

Residents within walking distance of grocery stores don't need big kitchens. They only need to store what they carry, not what they stuff into the car. Car based trips buy in quantity to reduce the number of trips, but need lots of storage space in the kitchen to store the foodstuffs.

Anonymous said...

What a great post. This guy O'Toole invented an interesting experiment which sounds awesome. In fact a few days back I was taking with a friend of mine about this guy who likes to visit
Viagra Online Without Prescription

Anonymous said...

I am looking to buy a small neighborhood store, and was wondering where you received your information? I am having trouble finding statistics to back up my financial plan.

Shiya Priya said...

Nice Website...
Hey JOIN now and Increase Facebook Likes your profile and websites.
Increase Facebook Likes and check your website worth

worth my websites
FB Likes and check your website worth Website Value Calculator
Hot Wallpapers
its may be very beneficial for you also really

Avinash Singh said...

Great information and glad to see stuff like this being posted. Lots of great information and inspiration, Thank you for the efforts you’ve put in writing this blog.
Grocery Delivery Services